Sharjah win brings clarity — and a selection headache
Pakistan brushed past UAE by 31 runs in the tri-nation T20I at the Sharjah Cricket Stadium on 4 September 2025, but the margin didn’t quiet the debate around team balance. The next toss could still spring a surprise. One name sits at the center of that discussion: Mohammad Nawaz.
The question isn’t just about one player. It’s about what Pakistan want from their No. 7/8 slot, how many spinners they trust on a dry Sharjah surface, and whether batting depth matters more than a specialist bowling option. That’s why the conversation around the Pakistan probable XI is less about a shortlist and more about roles.
Sharjah typically rewards smart pace off the ball, hard lengths, and bowling into the pitch. The square boundaries are short, but the surface can grip, especially if the match is early evening with minimal dew. Pakistan leaned on those basics in the win, and they’ll likely keep the core intact. The fine print is where Nawaz comes in: a left-arm spinner who can bat, field well, and bowl in the powerplay if needed. On paper, he fits Sharjah. In practice, his spot depends on whether the team wants an extra hitter or a different spin profile.
Pakistan’s selectors have two pressure points to solve. First, the second spinner slot alongside the leg-spin option. Second, the glue at No. 7/8: someone who can finish an innings at a strike rate the pitch demands and still offer four dependable overs if required.
Nawaz’s case, the alternatives, and three XI templates
Why Nawaz stays: he gives Pakistan variety. A left-arm angle in the middle overs is gold on worn surfaces, and he can slip in an over in the powerplay against a new right-hander. With the bat, he’s a break-glass option to target the short leg-side boundary. If Pakistan expect the pitch to slow down and they want control rather than chaos, Nawaz is a clean fit.
Why he could miss out: if Pakistan prefer a specialist legspinner for wicket-taking (chasing breakthroughs instead of containment) or if they want more batting at No. 7 with a seam-bowling allrounder who can clear the rope at the death. There’s also the match-up lens: UAE often line up right-hand heavy. Pakistan might fancy off-spin match-ups (think part-time options like Iftikhar Ahmed) over a second left-arm orthodox if the legspinner already covers middle-overs aggression.
Spin options if Nawaz sits: a wristspinner who turns it away from right-handers and hunts wickets; or an off-spin route to target right-handers’ pads with the short side in play. Pace options if they go light on spin: bring in a hit-the-deck seamer to double down on Sharjah’s low bounce and use cutters at the death. It’s riskier if dew shows up, but it gives Pakistan an extra finisher with the bat if they pick a seam allrounder.
Three likely XI templates Pakistan could use:
- Spin-control XI: two frontline spinners (left-arm orthodox + legspin), three quicks, and a batting line-up that trusts its top six to score. Nawaz stays; role is control and late hitting if needed.
- Wicket-hunting XI: one finger spinner, one legspinner, and an extra attacking quick. Nawaz misses out for a wristspinner who bowls the riskier, wicket-taking lengths. The batting gets a power-hitter at No. 7.
- Batting-depth XI: swap Nawaz for a seam-bowling allrounder to push a long batting card. You lose a bit of spin control but gain six genuine hitters, handy if Pakistan bat first and aim 180+.
Conditions call: if the pitch looks used and dusty, expect two spinners and Nawaz to be favored. If it’s firmer with a hint of sheen, Pakistan may back pace through the middle and choose a seam-bowling allrounder. If dew is forecast, a second spinner is a tougher sell unless he’s nailed-on for match-ups.
Five questions the team management is asking today:
- Does the surface look worn enough to demand two spinners?
- Are we getting more value from a wicket-taking legspinner or a control-oriented left-arm spinner?
- Do we need an extra hitter at No. 7, or can the top six carry the load?
- What are UAE’s likely right-hand/left-hand splits up top?
- Is dew likely after sunset, and does that punish our second spinner?
Players who shape the call: the legspinner (as the middle-overs striker), the senior left-arm quick up front with the new ball, and a death specialist who can bowl cutters into the pitch. If those three roles are locked, the final shirt goes to either Nawaz (control plus flexibility) or a batting-heavy allround option (firepower plus medium-pace variation).
What should fans watch at the toss? Two clues. First, the “second spinner” discussion—if Pakistan go with a legspinner-plus-finger-spinner combo, Nawaz’s chances rise. Second, the finisher slot—if the team sheet shows a designated seam allrounder, that likely means Nawaz sits and Pakistan chase hitting depth instead.
Bottom line: the 31-run win steadied Pakistan, but Sharjah rewards horses for courses. Nawaz isn’t out of the frame—far from it. His selection lives in the gap between control and aggression. If the pitch looks tired, he stays. If Pakistan want a higher ceiling with the bat or an extra wicket-taker, he’s the one who makes way.
Write a comment